Photography has no rules, it is not a sport. It is the result which counts, no matter how it is achieved.
Bill Brandt
Not everyone agrees with the above quote, I know, especially when it comes to editing. There are purists who say that only the shot as it came out of the camera is ‘true’. Others allow for a bit of mild cropping and straightening, nothing more. But some of us like to go further in the post-production editing process.
I do so for two different reasons. Most often it is to make the shot the best it can be. Sometimes it takes a bit of editing to create an image that feels like the scene felt to me at the time. The eye can play tricks on us, correcting dark shadows for instance. So I play with lighting, contrast, colour saturation until the image looks right.
But sometimes I take it further, using filters and effects to create something entirely different. I don’t see this as cheating, because it is always obvious that I have played with the image.
So this month I thought it was high time I joined the One-to-Three Photo Processing challenge. The aim is to ‘have some creative fun with photos’, just as I love to do!
The original
I started with a simple photo of a Great Tit, taken last summer in Shropshire. This has been cropped but otherwise is as it came out of the camera.
Edit one
For my first edit I used my favourite Color Efex Pro, one of the Nik Collection plug-ins, applying one of the vintage effect filters. I find these a simple but effective way of creating a mood. They work particularly well for flowers. Here I liked the way the effect brightened and softened the background, making the bird stand out a bit more.
Edit two
This second edit used a mix of Photoshop Elements and Color Efex. I used the dry brush filter in the former and then added the rough border from the selection in the latter, pushing it to the roughest and widest settings. I liked the way this makes the image look as if it has been torn from a book or magazine.
Edit three
For my final edit I turned to another favourite from the Nik Collection, Silver Efex Pro. I like monochrome edits and my original intention was simply to see what this shot looked like in black and white. But I felt it was rather dull, so I added a cyanotype tone and used a control point to bring back selective colour on the bird’s breast.
So there you have it; one Great Tit, three ways. I’ll be very interested to hear which edit is your favourite, if any, or whether perhaps you like the original best and think I should have left well alone!
45 Comments
lifelessons
This is a fabulous shot however edited.
Sarah Wilkie
Thank you 🙂 I was happy that he posed for a short while near where I was sitting!
Pingback:
SoyBend
I liked the second edit. It brightens the bird’s natural color and the frame helps focus or attention. Glad to see you participating in this challenge, Sarah!
Sarah Wilkie
The second seems to be a general favourite 🙂 I hope to join in again in future months – I love editing but I rarely try three different versions like this.
Annie Berger
I guess I’m going to be the odd one out here as my ‘favorite’ was actually number 3. I preferred the greater contrast between the color of the Great Tit and the branch as both elements stood out while still not competing for attention in my mind.
Sarah Wilkie
Haha, it’s actually good to find someone who prefers a different image, so thank you for that Annie 😀
Annie Berger
Glad to oblige;!
Easymalc
It’s still the original for me, but I endorse what you say about manipulating an image within the constrants of what it was intended to be – unless of course you take the picture with a mind to change it into something quite different.
Sarah Wilkie
Well that can be fun too of course Malcolm 😉😁
Easymalc
Too right! 🙂
giacomoasinello
Number 2 I think.
Sarah Wilkie
Thanks – I think it’s a tie between that one and the original right now 😀
I. J. Khanewala
I’m with the rest of the crowd today. The original is quite good actually, the greens in the background and in the moss on the branch moderate the bright colours of the tit. You still get quite a bit of that in number 2. The rest are too blue and the tit looks artificially bright.
Sarah Wilkie
Interesting, and I do see what you mean 😀
Rose
The original was my favorite. 😊
Sarah Wilkie
Thanks Rose 🙂 Many people seem to agree with you so maybe I should just leave well alone in the future!
RosalieAnn Beasley
I like the original and #2 because I prefer the photos that have more yellow in the branch to compliment the yellow in the bird. I don’t like the bluer ones.
Sarah Wilkie
Thanks Rosalie, that’s an interesting way of looking at it 🙂
wetanddustyroads
I thought I would like the original photo the most – I normally do. But then I was actually surprised at how much I liked your second edited photo … could it be because of the frame? I don’t know – it just feels “softer” ☺️.
Sarah Wilkie
Thank you for giving this some thought 🙂 I think the softer feel of the second edit is down to the dry brush effect which imitates a painting. I kept it quite subtle because I didn’t want to totally lose the texture of the feathers. I’m glad you like it 🙂
Teresa
I would like to say that I prefer the original one too. The Edit three comes a close second because it focuses more on the bird. Well, that’s just me.
Sarah Wilkie
Thanks Teresa, and I see what you mean about the third one. With no other colour around it the bright yellow stands out more!
Leela Gopinath
I like the original one….but learnt some editing tricks….thanks!
Sarah Wilkie
Thanks for the feedback, and glad to have shown you a few tricks!
margaret21
These all have their merits, but I prefer the original in this case. I think it gives the best flavour of the tit, and its habitat.
Sarah Wilkie
Thank you Margaret 🙂 I agree that if you want to learn anything about the bird the original does the best job. So maybe like Janet says below, it depends from day to day and also on what you are looking for from the shot?
margaret21
I think so. Ask us all for our opinions next week, and we might all choose differently.
Sarah Wilkie
😁
Manja Maksimovič
Yep. I needed one second. I prefer the original.
Sarah Wilkie
Haha, somehow I would have guessed that 😆
the eternal traveller
I like edit two best – not for any particular reason. It’s just the one I prefer.
Sarah Wilkie
Thanks, and yo don’t need a reason! Several people have picked that one out 🙂
sustainabilitea
I’m not avoiding the question but I think my favorite would depend on what day it was and how I felt that day. I like playing with frames although I know some really good photographers who never seem to use them. Some days I feel like just cropping is the best, sometimes saturating a bit to get the color I really saw, etc. I enjoyed them all but they certainly give different feels and emphasize things slightly differently.
janet
Sarah Wilkie
Thank you Janet, I think you may be right about changing your favourite from day to day. I had a favourite when I posted this, but reviewing them just now I leaned more towards a different one 😆
Monkey's Tale
I think I prefer the original, although I don’t have an artistic eye so maybe I just like natural. 😊
Sarah Wilkie
Nothing to do with an artistic eye in my opinion, simply that tastes differ. Views seem to be split between the original and edit two so far!
Heyjude
I prefer the original, though I’d crop it even tighter as I don’t think the background adds much to the image. The sticky up twig is distracting too. But it is never easy to capture these little birds.
Sarah Wilkie
Thanks Jude. I see what you mean about a tighter crop, but to me the ‘sticky up twig’ helps to frame the bird. Fun how we all see things differently 😆
Heyjude
Life would be boring if we were all the same 😉
Gradmama2011
My favorite is Edit Two. I like the colors, the way the tints are natural in the background…not sure what they call that, or rather how to spell the word. Also for me the minimal framing adds to the effect. The bird appears like it could fly away 🙂
Sarah Wilkie
Thank you, it’s great to get your feedback. I’ll reveal my own favourite when more people have commented!
kzmcb
I like the original best, but the last edit comes close.
Sarah Wilkie
Thanks for the feedback 🙂 Interesting that you pick out that last one as you’re the first person to comment on it. Views seem mostly to be split between the original and edit two so far!
kzmcb
I really liked the focus on the bird and, as someone else commented, the background is unimportant.