Black and white photography is truly quite a ‘departure from reality’
Ansel Adams
The terms ‘black and white’ and ‘monochrome’ are often used synonymously in photography. But when you consider the meaning of the latter you quickly realise that they need not be the same thing. A black and white photo can be described as monochrome, but a monochrome image isn’t necessarily black and white. Monochrome simply means ‘one colour’, so any photo dominated by shades of a single colour can be said to be monochrome.
On the subject of colours …
Last week for the Lens Artists challenge, I shared monochrome galleries in the three primary colours. The secondary colours are those that lie between the primary ones on the colour wheel and are formed by mixing them. In terms of paints or dyes (light is different), the primary shades are blue, red and yellow. By mixing blue and red we get purple. Mixing red and yellow we get orange. And mixing yellow and blue we get green.
For this week’s challenge from Anne, to illustrate my point about the difference between the terms ‘monochrome and ‘black and white’, I’ve selected some monochrome shots in those secondary colours and edited them as black and white. Both versions can be defined as monochrome, but which do you prefer?
Purple
The colour purple symbolises leadership and strength, and also with spirituality and creativity. Its richness is associated with royalty. Purple certainly makes a statement that’s hard to ignore!
Door detail, Cartagena, Colombia
Kings Cross station, London
At the Winter Lights event in London’s Docklands
Pansy in a planter in Blloku, Tirana
Orange
Orange stands for enthusiasm and emotion. It is full of the energy of sunlight and the warmth of a fire. It is an optimistic shade, less brash than red and more vivid than yellow.
Door detail, Tavira, Portugal
Cheetah fur close-up at a big cat sanctuary in Kent, England
In a planter in the 14th arrondissement, Paris
In a riad in Marrakesh
Green
The colour green symbolises harmony and health. It is the colour of nature, the colour that induces a sense of calm and relaxation. Unsurprisingly many of my monochrome greens come from the natural world, but not all.
Indian poke leaves (I think), Mount Rainier, WA
Palm leaves, Cayena Beach Villas, Colombia
In the Bamboo Grove, Arashiyama, Kyoto
House in Cartagena, Colombia
My featured photo is a selective colour edit of balloons on the Quayside in Newcastle. It was edited initially in Silver Efex Pro, and the colours tweaked in Color Efex Pro to match my chosen shades for this post.
60 Comments
Sue
Well done, like your approach to this
Sarah Wilkie
Thanks again Sue 🙂
Sue
My pleasure!
wetanddustyroads
I like the colour photos – the pansy is lovely, as is the photo in Marrakesh. But then again … the door in Portugal is stunning in B&W.
Sarah Wilkie
I’ve enjoyed hearing all the different views and preferences here 😃
rkrontheroad
A fascinating color study. They are all striking in their own way.
Sarah Wilkie
Thank you Ruth 😊
Wetravelhappy
I like this post a lot Sarah! You are so creative. It’s a brilliant idea to use the ‘comparison’ mode for this challenge. Whoever started this challenge must be very proud and satisfied with your contribution.
Sarah Wilkie
Thanks so much 😊 It was Anne who set the challenge and from her comment below it seems she likes my response!
norasphotos4u
This is so creative! It was great to see the differences. Love the balloon photo too!
Sarah Wilkie
Thank you Nora, I’m glad you enjoyed this so much 🙂
Paul
Very creative and educational approach. I don’t think it will surprise you that, for the most part, I choose black and white. That said, King’s Cross and the Winter Lights are striking in the monochrome.
Sarah Wilkie
Thank you Paul – and no, not surprised at all 😀
margaret21
It’s taken me till now to have the time to read your post properly: it must have taken ages to prepare so the least I could do was give it my attention. What an interesting experiment. I think b/w works really well with geometry or patterns, or even with plants that are structural rather than floral. But I’ll take some convincing that flowers are well served in black and white. The doors and the house in Cartagena work well in both. It depends, I guess on the mood you’re trying to establish in showing such a photo. A great post!
Sarah Wilkie
It took a while, yes, so thank you for taking the time to look properly 😊 I do see what you mean about flowers, but while they will always look lovely in colour, I feel those with interesting structures and/or textures often also look good in B&W in a very different way. It brings out those aspects that you don’t always notice so much when focusing on the beautiful colours.
margaret21
That’s very true. But then I like the tips that the b/w has given me to return to the colour with fresh appreciation.
Anita
Cleverly presented so we can compare Sarah. I thought I would choose all of them in color but looking closer at your photos I notice that some actually do better in black and white, although there were only two. Kings Cross station and the Winter Lights event. You may know me by now, I love the power of colours. 😀
Sarah Wilkie
Thank you Anita. It”s so interesting that different people are drawn to different images and to black and white or to colour!
grandmisadventures
oh these are incredible! I love seeing the color and the black and white side by side 🙂
Sarah Wilkie
Thanks so much 😀 I’m glad you enjoyed the slider effect!
Brad M
Good examples of color vs. B&W. Differrent details catch your eye with each technique. I was wondering, halfway through reading, what would photographing a B&W subject in color be called? 😉
Sarah Wilkie
Interesting question!
rosalieann37
I feel that black and white is a newer form of monochrome. Most of the early photos that I see are more brown than black.
Sarah Wilkie
Hmm, I’m not sure that’s the case. Many old family photos are sepia but there are lots of great truly B&W photographers from the earlier years!
Yanti
Wonderful photos and the slider function is so interesting, Sarah!
Sarah Wilkie
Thank you – I do enjoy using that slider 😀
thehungrytravellers.blog
Great photos. I’m not sure I’m ….err….creative (?) enough to link colours to characteristics or emotions, I struggle to make the link. I always like your black and white shots when they are moody….cloudy days, industrial scenes, and the like
Sarah Wilkie
Thank you Phil ☺️
Mike and Kellye Hefner
What a fun post, Sarah! I enjoyed sliding the arrows to see the comparisons. I hope you are having a wonderful trip.
Sarah Wilkie
Thanks Kellye, we’re having a great time although it’s a little hot for sightseeing!
Mike and Kellye Hefner
Ah, so summer has finally arrived in Europe?
Sarah Wilkie
We had summer in June and are having it again in September, but it took an extended break in July and August!
Mike and Kellye Hefner
It looks like you’re having a great time despite the heat.
Sarah Wilkie
In Paris? Always!!
Wind Kisses
Fantastic Sarah! Not only did I love the photos, I loved the comparisons. It gave the viewer a chance to see the power of monochrome, or if it is color to bring it to light. Always a pleasure. Purple was my fave this week
Sarah Wilkie
Thanks so much Siobhan ☺️ I think purple is my favourite too!
Linda K
What a fun thing to play around with. I’ve done some editing where I remove all except one bold colour, but haven’t played around much with taking a coloured photo and turning it black and white. I love what you’ve done with the monochrome images and how the change to black and white really changes the whole mood in some of them. I do prefer the monochrome though 🙂
Sarah Wilkie
Thank you for that detailed feedback Linda. I really enjoy playing around with B&W edits 😀
SoyBend
Unique take on the challenge and great use of the slider tool, Sarah! I especially liked the Kings Cross Station and the palm leaves.
Sarah Wilkie
Thanks so much Siobhan 😀 The slider seemed ideal for this post!
restlessjo
Nice approach, Sarah, though a few of them have too many colours in for me to regard them as mono. Love the Tavira door, of course! Black and white can look very washed out if you don’t have the right subject matter. I enjoyed browsing your informal look at Paris on Facebook today.
Sarah Wilkie
Thank you Jo – I confess I was aware I was slightly pushing my luck with the mono claim on a couple of them! Glad you’re enjoying my Paris photos, many of which will appear in Monday Walks some time soon no doubt 😉
restlessjo
I look forward to that. Lovely Paris!
Tina Schell
A very interesting approach this week Sarah! Some lovely comparisons. My two favorites are the poke leaves and the bamboo groves, both in their original greens. Of the B&Ws I favored the Marrakesh which I think takes the most advantage of the light and shadows. Terrific post.
Sarah Wilkie
Thank you Tina 😊 That poke leaves shot is one of my own favourites but I find it hard to choose between colour and B&W!
salsaworldtraveler
I have to say that generally both versions work for me except for the house in Cartagena. The color version is far superior in my view.
Sarah Wilkie
Thank you, very interesting to get your feedback 😀
Leya
Beautiful comparisons, Sarah – all of them. I cannot pick a favourite!
Sarah Wilkie
Thank you so much 😊
Sofia Alves
I don’t know how you managed but I think they all work beautifully, it just depend on the mood your looking for, more or less textures… I love the way your presented them too. Favourite, if I had to pick one, would be the bamboo one in b&w and I can’t really explain why.
Sarah Wilkie
No need for explanations Sofia, I just appreciate your feedback 😊
Egídio
Lovely photo comparisons. You make it difficult to choose in each case. These are beautiful examples.
Sarah Wilkie
Thank you – if it’s hard to choose I think I’ve done my job well!
Smile Quotes 24
Nice and interesting post, thank you for sharing
Belle Famose Citazioni
XingfuMama
I don’t usually prefer one or the the other. To me, the two versions draw attention to different aspects of the subject. The black and whites make the lines and textures stand out.
Sarah Wilkie
Yes, that’s a good point – they can each emphasise different elements of shot but not necessarily be better than the other
Anne Sandler
This is a great and creative approach to this challenge Sarah. In most cases, I like the B&W versions of your images, but some of them do look better in color. I think the beauty is in the eye of the beholder. Art is so subjective!
Sarah Wilkie
Thank you Anne 😊 I’m glad I was able to get this done before going away as it was a fun but also thought-provoking challenge.
JohnRH
Hmm. Great comparisons. I’m partial to color, though I like greyscale contrasts such as the Docklands photo, or foggy shots, or…
Sarah Wilkie
Thank you 😀 In other words, it’s hard to choose?!